Five Top Picks From the Five Guys Menu With Prices
Trying to choose the best Five Guys meal without overspending can be challenging. You’re not alone—many people want generous portions, tasty options, and a price that fits their budget.
This guide highlights five top picks from the Five Guys menu with prices to help you order with confidence.
Five Guys’ top picks include the Bacon Cheeseburger, Little Cheeseburger, Regular Fries, Milkshake, and a customized burger with free toppings.
Expect to spend roughly $15–$25 per person, though prices vary by location and extras.
Choose the Little Cheeseburger for a lighter, lower-cost meal, or order the Bacon Cheeseburger when you’re hungrier.
Regular Fries offer generous portions that you can share, while shakes add a creamy treat.
You’ll find more ways to maximize value and customize your order below.
Key Takeaways
- Bacon Cheeseburger: Double beef patties, American cheese, and bacon; typically costs about $10–$15, depending on location.
- Little Cheeseburger: A lighter single-patty option with two cheese slices, usually priced around $7–$11.
- Regular Fries: A generous, shareable portion typically costing approximately $5–$8.
- Milkshake: Thick, customizable shakes with flavors and mix-ins, generally priced around $6–$9.
- Hot Dog: A customizable grilled hot dog, commonly costing about $6–$10; verify local menu pricing online.
What Does Five Guys Cost?
Five Guys costs a little more than many fast-food chains, with burgers, fries, and shakes often adding up to about $15–$25 per person. You’ll usually pay more for a made-to-order burger than for a basic combo elsewhere, but generous portions can make the meal feel worthwhile.
Five Guys typically costs $15–$25 per person, but generous portions and made-to-order quality can make the meal worthwhile.
A regular burger costs more than a little hamburger, while bacon, cheese, and extra patties raise the total. Fries also come in larger servings than you might expect, so you may save money by sharing one order.
Your final bill depends on location, since Five Guys sets prices by market. Drinks, shakes, mix-ins, and hot dogs add to the cost, too.
Menu customization lets you choose toppings without paying extra for many standard options, although premium additions can increase your total. Before ordering, check the restaurant’s online menu and Nutritional information for current prices, calories, allergens, and portion details.
That way, you can match your order to your budget and appetite.
How We Ranked the Five Best Picks
To rank the five best Five Guys picks, we compared flavor, portion size, customization, popularity, and overall value. You’ll see choices that deliver satisfying meals without relying on hype or one narrow preference.
We considered how easily you can adjust each order, whether its ingredients work together, and how well the serving size matches its price.
We also looked beyond taste so you can choose with confidence:
- Flavor combinations that balance savory, fresh, and rich ingredients
- Portion sizes that suit different appetites
- Customization options for personal preferences
- Popularity among regular customers
- Nutritional insights for more informed decisions
Your priorities may differ, so this ranking isn’t a strict rulebook. Instead, it highlights versatile orders that perform well across several categories.
We weighed menu consistency, ingredient quality, and practical value while keeping prices in mind. That approach helps you compare each pick fairly before choosing the meal that best fits your hunger, budget, and preferred way to customize your order.
1. Bacon Cheeseburger: Best Classic Order
The Bacon Cheeseburger earns the top spot for a satisfying, familiar meal with plenty of room to customize. You get two beef patties, melted American cheese, and crispy bacon, creating a rich, savory combination that feels indulgent without being complicated.
Add your favorite Cheeseburger toppings, such as grilled onions, jalapeños, mushrooms, pickles, or fresh lettuce and tomato, to balance the smoky bacon and creamy cheese. The standard bun keeps everything together, while the generous filling makes each bite substantial.
Customize with grilled onions, jalapeños, mushrooms, pickles, lettuce, or tomato to balance the smoky bacon and creamy cheese.
For Burger customization, you can choose as many included toppings as you like, so your order can stay classic or take on a bolder flavor. Pair it with fresh-cut fries and a drink for a complete meal.
Prices vary by location, but this burger generally costs more than simpler menu choices because of its double-patty build and extra bacon. If you want Five Guys’ signature burger experience, this is the dependable order to try first.
It’s filling, flavorful, and easy to personalize.
2. Little Cheeseburger: Best Lower-Cost Burger
When you want a lighter burger without giving up Five Guys’ signature flavor, the Little Cheeseburger is a smart, lower-cost choice. It features one fresh beef patty and two slices of American cheese, giving you a satisfying bite without the size or price of the larger burgers.
You can make it your own with plenty of Burger toppings, all included in the base price.
- Add grilled onions for sweetness.
- Choose jalapeños for extra heat.
- Try mushrooms for an earthy finish.
- Pick lettuce and tomato for freshness.
- Keep it simple with ketchup and pickles.
This burger works especially well when you want flexibility. Meal customization lets you build a combination that matches your appetite, whether you prefer bold flavors or a straightforward cheeseburger.
Because the patty is smaller, you won’t feel as weighed down, yet the cheese and fresh toppings still create a complete meal. Check your local menu for current pricing, as costs can vary by location.
Choose Regular Fries when you want a generous side to share. They’re cooked fresh to order, so every bite is hot and crispy. The ample serving pairs perfectly with burgers and other menu favorites, making them an easy choice for the table.
Generous Serving Size
Regular fries make the best shareable side at Five Guys because one order delivers a generous portion for the table. You’ll notice the portion size feels designed for sharing, especially when your group orders burgers, hot dogs, or sandwiches.
The serving presentation also adds to the experience: fries arrive piled high in the cup, with an extra scoop spilling into the bag.
That abundance gives everyone an easy way to grab a satisfying handful without ordering several sides. You can split the order across the table or keep it nearby for casual snacking.
A regular serving works well for:
- Two diners sharing a meal
- Families adding one communal side
- Groups sampling multiple menu items
- Guests wanting extra bites
- Budget-minded orders
Because you get so much in one order, regular fries deliver excellent value and make sharing simple.
Crispy, Freshly Cooked
That generous portion tastes even better because Five Guys cooks its fries fresh to order. You can expect hot, golden potatoes with a satisfying contrast between crisp edges and tender centers.
Those crispy textures give every bite a lively crunch without overpowering the potato’s natural taste. Since the kitchen prepares each order after you request it, your fries arrive warm rather than sitting under a heat lamp.
Fresh flavors come through clearly, especially when you choose Five Guys’ skin-on style, which adds an earthy note and hearty character. You can enjoy them plain or add a sprinkle of salt to highlight their savory flavor.
The regular fries deliver dependable quality, making them an easy choice when you want a freshly cooked side with your burger or sandwich.
Perfect For Sharing
When you’re sharing a meal, the regular fries give everyone plenty to enjoy without taking over the table. You can pass the carton around, grab a handful, and pair each bite with burgers, hot dogs, or sandwiches. Their generous portion makes them a practical choice for groups, especially when you want one side everyone can enjoy.
- Easy to pass around
- Crisp outside, tender inside
- Complements every entrée
- Great with ketchup or malt vinegar
- Helps complete a shared order
You’ll also appreciate how the fries fit any dining atmosphere, from a quick lunch to a relaxed family dinner. Before ordering, check the restaurant’s nutritional information if you’re tracking calories, sodium, or portion sizes.
Since Five Guys cooks fries to order, you can enjoy them hot while your group settles in and shares the meal together. Their familiar flavor keeps the table happy without requiring separate side orders for everyone.
4. Milkshake: Best Sweet Add-On
A Five Guys milkshake is the best sweet add-on when you want to finish your meal with something rich and customizable. You can choose from several Milkshake varieties, including classic chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and coffee. If you prefer a bolder flavor, mix in options such as bacon, peanut butter, salted caramel, or Oreo cookie pieces. These Sweet add on options let you create a dessert that matches your cravings without ordering a separate specialty treat.
Each shake starts with a thick, creamy base that pairs well with burgers, hot dogs, and fries. You’ll get a generous serving, so it works as a satisfying dessert or a shareable extra after your meal. Prices vary by location, but the milkshake typically offers good value for its size and flavor. Add one to your order when you want a cool, indulgent finish that feels more personal than a standard fast-food dessert. You won’t need anything else.
5. Custom Toppings: Best Way to Personalize
Custom toppings make Five Guys one of the easiest fast-food orders to personalize. You can build a burger, hot dog, or sandwich around your favorite textures and flavors without settling for a standard combination.
Five Guys lets you create a personalized burger, hot dog, or sandwich with toppings that match your favorite flavors and textures.
The menu offers plenty of free choices, so you can keep your order simple or create bold flavor combinations. Consider these popular additions:
- Grilled onions for sweetness
- Jalapeño peppers for heat
- Pickles for a tangy crunch
- Fresh mushrooms for earthy flavor
- A1 sauce for savory depth
You can also add lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, relish, mustard, mayonnaise, barbecue sauce, and hot sauce. Try pairing grilled mushrooms with grilled onions, or balance spicy peppers with creamy mayonnaise.
These topping variations let you adjust each bite to match your preferences. If you’re ordering for someone else, ask about every topping before checking out, since customization makes it easier to satisfy different tastes.
Your ideal combination might become your regular order, whether you prefer fresh, smoky, spicy, or tangy flavors.
Compare Five Guys Burgers by Price and Size
Five Guys burgers vary in price and size, so you should compare your appetite with your budget before ordering. A Little Burger offers one patty and costs less, making it a practical choice when you want a lighter meal or a lower total.
The regular Hamburger includes two patties, so you’ll pay more but receive a heartier portion. You can also choose cheeseburgers or bacon burgers; each added Burger ingredient raises the price, while combined toppings can make your order more filling without changing the patty count.
Check your location’s menu because prices differ by restaurant and may change over time. Consider your dining atmosphere, too: a casual dine-in meal may suit a substantial burger, while a quick takeaway could call for the smaller option.
Compare patty count, cheese, bacon, and toppings before you order. That approach helps you match portion size to hunger and avoid paying for more burger than you’ll enjoy.
Choose Regular or Large Fries
After choosing your burger size, decide whether regular or large fries fit your appetite and budget. Five Guys serves generous portions, so a regular order may satisfy one hungry customer, especially alongside a burger. A large order can work better for sharing, but it also costs more and may leave leftovers.
Consider these points before ordering:
- Regular fries suit a lighter meal.
- Large fries provide extra food for sharing.
- Both sizes come with the signature Fries seasoning.
- Expect more than the container seems to hold.
- Check the menu price before confirming your choice.
Your appetite matters as much as the listed price. If you’re eating alone and prefer minimal waste, choose regular.
If you’ve got a big appetite or someone wants to split fries, large offers more value per serving. You can also ask for your preferred seasoning level, since the salty finish adds noticeable flavor.
Either way, the portion size may surprise you, so don’t underestimate the regular option when planning your meal.
Build the Best-Value Five Guys Order
To get the best value, choose the burger size and fry portion that match your appetite, then add only the toppings and drink you’ll enjoy. A Little Burger can satisfy a lighter appetite, while a regular burger offers two patties for a heartier meal.
Since Five Guys serves generous fries, split an order with a friend or choose Little Fries instead of automatically upgrading. Use Meal customization to build flavor without paying for extras you won’t eat.
Free toppings, including grilled onions, jalapeños, pickles, and mushrooms, let you personalize your burger at no additional cost. If you’re ordering a shake, select only the mix-ins you’ll finish; combining several can raise the price quickly.
Check current menu prices and Nutritional information before ordering, especially if you’re watching calories, sodium, or portion sizes. You’ll get better value by planning your complete order rather than adding items impulsively at the counter or through the app.
Share fries, skip unnecessary add-ons, and enjoy your meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Five Guys Offer Vegetarian Burger Options?
Yes, you’ll find vegetarian options at Five Guys, but you won’t find plant based burgers or a dedicated veggie patty. You can order a grilled cheese sandwich, a veggie sandwich, or a cheese veggie sandwich, then customize it with toppings such as grilled onions, mushrooms, lettuce, tomatoes, and peppers.
Keep in mind that Five Guys cooks vegetables on the same grill as meat, so cross-contact may matter if you have strict dietary needs.
If you have a peanut allergy, you shouldn’t consider Five Guys menu items reliably safe. Five Guys uses peanuts throughout its restaurants, and its fries cook in peanut oil.
Cross contamination can occur through shared equipment, surfaces, utensils, or airborne peanut exposure. Although refined peanut oil may affect some people differently, you need to ask staff about ingredients and procedures before ordering.
For severe allergies, you’ll likely want to choose another restaurant.
Can I Order Five Guys Online for Delivery?
Yes, you can order Five Guys online for delivery through the restaurant’s website, app, or participating third-party services, depending on your location.
Select your nearest restaurant, choose your meal, and review available ordering options before checkout. You’ll see delivery fees, taxes, and potential service charges in your total.
Availability, delivery areas, estimated times, and prices vary by restaurant, so confirm the details carefully before placing your order.
Does Five Guys Provide Nutritional and Allergen Information?
Yes, Five Guys provides nutritional and allergen information, so you don’t have to guess, even if its customizable menu seems complicated. You can review calorie counts, common allergens, and ingredient details through the company’s official nutrition and allergen resources.
Ingredient transparency helps you make informed choices, but recipes and preparation methods may change. If you have a severe allergy, confirm details with your local restaurant and explain your needs before ordering to reduce cross-contact risks.
Are Five Guys Locations Open for Breakfast?
No, you generally won’t find Five Guys locations open for breakfast. Most restaurants begin serving lunch around 11:00 a.m., though exact breakfast hours can vary by location.
You should check your nearby restaurant’s listing or call ahead before visiting, especially on weekends or holidays. Five Guys typically doesn’t offer a dedicated breakfast menu, so menu variations usually reflect location-specific availability rather than morning meals.
You’ll find burgers, hot dogs, fries, and shakes instead.
Conclusion
Five Guys prices reward smart choices. You can treat the Bacon Cheeseburger like a familiar American classic, choose a Little Cheeseburger when your wallet needs a lighter touch, and split Regular Fries as a table-sharing treasure.
Add free toppings to turn each order into your own culinary map. Before you order, compare sizes and prices, then build a meal that fits both your appetite and budget. The best value isn’t hidden; it’s waiting beneath the red-and-white sign.
These top picks from the Five Guys menu with prices make it easier to enjoy a satisfying meal while staying within your budget.
